The death of Dan Wheldon is certainly a tragedy. As a person who doesn't really care for NASCAR or IndyCar, watching a successful young man, with a wife and kid die prematurely in a largely preventable manner is heartbreaking regardless.
Not that it changes anything about the death, really, the fact that he won the Indianapolis 500 back in May certainly leaves an even greater bitter taste in the mouth.
And I am okay with the amount of coverage that his death has received. Obviously, for a sport that is as popular as IndyCar, it should be expected. But my problem is what some media outlets are choosing to cover in this tragic incident.
The day after Wheldon's death, it was widely circulated that just the night before he died, he and his wife were tattooing the other's initials on their body as a sign of their love and dedication. A personal decision, done for personal reasons, because of personal feelings for their love.
So tell me why that story deserves a segment on Sportscenter? Not just a story about the death, but specifically about the tattoos. Why does there need to be an AP recap of that? Why should that story appear on Deadspin? A personal moment and gesture, made public to turn this hardship into a tear-jerking, sob story.
The nature of the sporting world has removed the privacy once protected for intimate moments such as Wheldon and his wife's. The media searches for every angle of a story to capture readers and viewers, exploiting the indelible pain that Wheldon's wife experiences.
Facts are what should be reported. And the public certainly receives the facts. But intimate anecdotes like this should remain private. No parties, particularly Wheldon's wife and family, benefits from it.
Sports, public relations and impassioned rants throughout. Commentary from the peanut gallery is encouraged.
Tuesday, 18 October 2011
Monday, 17 October 2011
For the Sake of Tradition, and Higher Quality Play
If you are a soccer fan and you haven't had the chance to check out this piece on ESPN about a possible change to the EPL's setup, I highly suggest taking a couple minutes to read it.
For those of you who don't want to, I'll rehash it here. Basically, as foreign ownership of English Premier League teams increases, the mumbling of a possible alteration to the system of relegation and promotion grows more audible. Each year, the bottom three teams from the EPL are relegated to the first division, and the top three teams of the first division take the place of the teams relegated.
This is the way it always has been in the EPL. I am not usually one to defend tradition, especially in the cases were tradition is outdated and no longer beneficial. But to abolish one of the central points of the EPL seems utterly absurd. In my opinion, having a relegation system keeps teams from becoming complacent. There is a constant need to improve the team, the youth system, the coaches, everything, because if teams don't, then they run the risk of relegation.
What does foreign ownership have to do with a desire for change? These men who own the teams want to protect their investments, and if their team is relegated, then their team's value will depreciate. But look no further than our backyard to know why this a bad idea to get rid of relegation. In American professional sports, too many owners care about their team as a business, and not as a sports team. For every one Jerry Buss (Lakers owner), there are too many Rob Sarvers (Suns owner), Donald Sterling (Clippers owner), and Michael Heisley (Grizzlies owner) who are too concerned with whether their team turns a profit rather than wins games. And if the EPL stopped relegating teams, then we would see an rise in the number of owners who care more about money than they do championships.
Relegation and promotion guarantees a more competitive league from year to year. It is the way the league has always been and should remain. But if more foreign ownership continues to move into EPL territory, it could put an end to the system. For the sake of tradition and the quality of the game, I sure hope not.
For those of you who don't want to, I'll rehash it here. Basically, as foreign ownership of English Premier League teams increases, the mumbling of a possible alteration to the system of relegation and promotion grows more audible. Each year, the bottom three teams from the EPL are relegated to the first division, and the top three teams of the first division take the place of the teams relegated.
This is the way it always has been in the EPL. I am not usually one to defend tradition, especially in the cases were tradition is outdated and no longer beneficial. But to abolish one of the central points of the EPL seems utterly absurd. In my opinion, having a relegation system keeps teams from becoming complacent. There is a constant need to improve the team, the youth system, the coaches, everything, because if teams don't, then they run the risk of relegation.
What does foreign ownership have to do with a desire for change? These men who own the teams want to protect their investments, and if their team is relegated, then their team's value will depreciate. But look no further than our backyard to know why this a bad idea to get rid of relegation. In American professional sports, too many owners care about their team as a business, and not as a sports team. For every one Jerry Buss (Lakers owner), there are too many Rob Sarvers (Suns owner), Donald Sterling (Clippers owner), and Michael Heisley (Grizzlies owner) who are too concerned with whether their team turns a profit rather than wins games. And if the EPL stopped relegating teams, then we would see an rise in the number of owners who care more about money than they do championships.
Relegation and promotion guarantees a more competitive league from year to year. It is the way the league has always been and should remain. But if more foreign ownership continues to move into EPL territory, it could put an end to the system. For the sake of tradition and the quality of the game, I sure hope not.
Tuesday, 20 September 2011
Body Image and Sports
As a student majoring in communications and psychology, I find myself reading many articles and studies about the struggles that women endure daily in regards to body image. Obviously, anyone who tries to argue against the enormous pressure the media, from news, to movies, to magazines, places on women to remain slender has clearly not paid very close attention to this issue. Many times, I find myself grateful that as a male, these pressures hardly seem to exist in comparison to the modern woman's struggle.
But it dawned on me one day, males do face these same issues, but often times it is overlooked. In the world of sports, a seemingly insurmountable amount of pressure to perform at a certain level has burdened the life of many male (and female, but for the purpose of this post, I will focus on males) youth. And how will they eventually perform at this level? By crafting and shaping their bodies to fit this ideal of what a male athlete should resemble.
High school, middle school and even as young as grade school athletes train longer and more intensely than ever before. Parents, coaches, fellow teammates, scouts opponents are the primary sources that provide this pressure both directly and indirectly. In football, offensive lineman lift and eat more to try and add that extra pound. Receivers and defensive backs run more sprints and perform more cone drills to increase speed and agility. In running, distance runners strive to shed that extra pound to lighten their load in races. Every sport has some bodily ideal that the athlete competes towards.
But what is the cost? More and more athletes turn to steroids and other performance enhancing drugs to push their body to the limit. They lift earlier in age and longer. The endure multiple practices in a day. Training camps, off-season tournaments, personal trainers. The need for males athletes to perform a certain level directly correlates to how their body is developed both genetically and through hard work. Those whose genes were not quite as strong have to work that much harder to reach the pinnacle of their abilities.
Having competed in both cross country and track, I can attest to the enormous pressure that exists to look like the elite runners. You eat a little less, run a longer and more often, but to what gain? With those days behind me, I often wonder why we place so much focus on how we appear as athletes.
Every night the gym is packed. Weights clang together. Protein shakes are the drink of choice. This culture of pushing your body to the limit manifests itself early and can eat away at a male's self-esteem. With so much focus on the same issue, but in regards to women, often times the idea that males could struggle with this is swept under the rug.
Unfortunately, I have no solution to the problem. But simply knowing that there is an issue is the first step to addressing it. Males, and athletes in particular, face an enormous pressure to look and perform at a certain level and it is an issue I believe is worth noting.
But it dawned on me one day, males do face these same issues, but often times it is overlooked. In the world of sports, a seemingly insurmountable amount of pressure to perform at a certain level has burdened the life of many male (and female, but for the purpose of this post, I will focus on males) youth. And how will they eventually perform at this level? By crafting and shaping their bodies to fit this ideal of what a male athlete should resemble.
High school, middle school and even as young as grade school athletes train longer and more intensely than ever before. Parents, coaches, fellow teammates, scouts opponents are the primary sources that provide this pressure both directly and indirectly. In football, offensive lineman lift and eat more to try and add that extra pound. Receivers and defensive backs run more sprints and perform more cone drills to increase speed and agility. In running, distance runners strive to shed that extra pound to lighten their load in races. Every sport has some bodily ideal that the athlete competes towards.
But what is the cost? More and more athletes turn to steroids and other performance enhancing drugs to push their body to the limit. They lift earlier in age and longer. The endure multiple practices in a day. Training camps, off-season tournaments, personal trainers. The need for males athletes to perform a certain level directly correlates to how their body is developed both genetically and through hard work. Those whose genes were not quite as strong have to work that much harder to reach the pinnacle of their abilities.
Having competed in both cross country and track, I can attest to the enormous pressure that exists to look like the elite runners. You eat a little less, run a longer and more often, but to what gain? With those days behind me, I often wonder why we place so much focus on how we appear as athletes.
Every night the gym is packed. Weights clang together. Protein shakes are the drink of choice. This culture of pushing your body to the limit manifests itself early and can eat away at a male's self-esteem. With so much focus on the same issue, but in regards to women, often times the idea that males could struggle with this is swept under the rug.
Unfortunately, I have no solution to the problem. But simply knowing that there is an issue is the first step to addressing it. Males, and athletes in particular, face an enormous pressure to look and perform at a certain level and it is an issue I believe is worth noting.
Wednesday, 17 August 2011
The NCAA: Only One Way Out
In the past year, the NCAA seems to have read the press about them turning a blind eye towards corruption and politicking in college football. Someone in the public relations department raised a red flag and said, "Guys, we may want to repair our image a little bit. People think that we have no control over the situations."
Well, the public is right. The NCAA doesn't have control over their constituents. The cheating, recruiting violations, payments made to players, and cover-ups have run rampant through college football over the past two decades. So last year, during the summer, the NCAA decided, albeit never officially announced, they had to address the issues. Forget that the NCAA likely knew of most of these infractions, but played oblivious because ultimately these teams made billions of dollars for the two-faced organization. Public perception of the leagues and officials were Titanically low and to remedy the situation the NCAA started throwing around punishments and sanctions without impunity.
It started with USC, Reggie Bush and OJ Mayo. From there they moved to North Carolina. To Ohio State. Oregon. LSU. Georgia Tech. Boise State. And most recently Miami. The NCAA has started investigating every incident possible, revoking scholarships and banning teams from postseason appearances. The iron fist they threw around actually started to instill a sense of confidence as the violators were finally being punished, or at least investigated.
Sure, the NCAA has a list of problems with its infrastructure that might make the EU blush. But at least they started taking steps to address some of the more pressing issues. Maybe there was hope for this widely regarded corrupt organization.
But, unsurprisingly, the NCAA took a black eye with this Miami incident. The articles on the internet want to point the finger at Miami because it is a flashy plot with a storied program. I'm more interested in seeing what the NCAA will do.
The black eye comes from the fact that the same person who started the whole firestorm of attacks on programs, beginning with USC, Paul Dee, was the athletic director at the time of Miami's biggest transgressions. Dee was the chairman for the Committee of Infractions in the case against USC. The man responsible for the harshest punishment short of SMU's death penalty finds himself in the center of the biggest college-football scandal ever.
What will the NCAA do? The progress they appeared to make seems tainted now. Dee rode his high horse through Trojan territory, condemning the program and their ethics. Has there been a bigger example of hypocrisy in sporting history? Could the NCAA look any worse, in the wake of these investigations, having hired Dee to tackle the USC issue?
Fortunately for Dee, and unfortunately for the NCAA, he is retired and no longer has an association with the NCAA. They can drag his name through the mud, cry they were misled, or ban him from college football forever. None of it will really matter. The only thing the NCAA can do right now is turn its attention to Miami and their inevitable punishment.
Whether Miami is the powerhouse they were in the 90's, or having Jacory Harris throw more completed passes to the other team than his own, they draw national attention. Miami makes money. They are a big name program that the NCAA would love to see return to the days of past glory. And as a big name in a weak conference, Miami helps keep the ACC relevant even when they aren't running the table.
Now? The NCAA doesn't have a choice. If they want the public to take them seriously, they will drop the guillotine. It does not matter if it is a big-name program like Miami or not, the death penalty is the only option for the NCAA. They have to prove to coaches, boosters, athletic directors and university presidents that they are serious about these infractions. And your school's name won't have a say in the matter.
That same decision made last summer to actively pursue offenders needs to repeat itself. The NCAA is undoubtedly embarrassed by having chaired Dee, but they can salvage a piece of dignity here. But if the NCAA doesn't act, and act quickly, the damage will already be done. And all of those revoked scholarships and sanctions won't me a thing to the other schools still uncaught.
Well, the public is right. The NCAA doesn't have control over their constituents. The cheating, recruiting violations, payments made to players, and cover-ups have run rampant through college football over the past two decades. So last year, during the summer, the NCAA decided, albeit never officially announced, they had to address the issues. Forget that the NCAA likely knew of most of these infractions, but played oblivious because ultimately these teams made billions of dollars for the two-faced organization. Public perception of the leagues and officials were Titanically low and to remedy the situation the NCAA started throwing around punishments and sanctions without impunity.
It started with USC, Reggie Bush and OJ Mayo. From there they moved to North Carolina. To Ohio State. Oregon. LSU. Georgia Tech. Boise State. And most recently Miami. The NCAA has started investigating every incident possible, revoking scholarships and banning teams from postseason appearances. The iron fist they threw around actually started to instill a sense of confidence as the violators were finally being punished, or at least investigated.
Sure, the NCAA has a list of problems with its infrastructure that might make the EU blush. But at least they started taking steps to address some of the more pressing issues. Maybe there was hope for this widely regarded corrupt organization.
But, unsurprisingly, the NCAA took a black eye with this Miami incident. The articles on the internet want to point the finger at Miami because it is a flashy plot with a storied program. I'm more interested in seeing what the NCAA will do.
The black eye comes from the fact that the same person who started the whole firestorm of attacks on programs, beginning with USC, Paul Dee, was the athletic director at the time of Miami's biggest transgressions. Dee was the chairman for the Committee of Infractions in the case against USC. The man responsible for the harshest punishment short of SMU's death penalty finds himself in the center of the biggest college-football scandal ever.
What will the NCAA do? The progress they appeared to make seems tainted now. Dee rode his high horse through Trojan territory, condemning the program and their ethics. Has there been a bigger example of hypocrisy in sporting history? Could the NCAA look any worse, in the wake of these investigations, having hired Dee to tackle the USC issue?
Fortunately for Dee, and unfortunately for the NCAA, he is retired and no longer has an association with the NCAA. They can drag his name through the mud, cry they were misled, or ban him from college football forever. None of it will really matter. The only thing the NCAA can do right now is turn its attention to Miami and their inevitable punishment.
Whether Miami is the powerhouse they were in the 90's, or having Jacory Harris throw more completed passes to the other team than his own, they draw national attention. Miami makes money. They are a big name program that the NCAA would love to see return to the days of past glory. And as a big name in a weak conference, Miami helps keep the ACC relevant even when they aren't running the table.
Now? The NCAA doesn't have a choice. If they want the public to take them seriously, they will drop the guillotine. It does not matter if it is a big-name program like Miami or not, the death penalty is the only option for the NCAA. They have to prove to coaches, boosters, athletic directors and university presidents that they are serious about these infractions. And your school's name won't have a say in the matter.
That same decision made last summer to actively pursue offenders needs to repeat itself. The NCAA is undoubtedly embarrassed by having chaired Dee, but they can salvage a piece of dignity here. But if the NCAA doesn't act, and act quickly, the damage will already be done. And all of those revoked scholarships and sanctions won't me a thing to the other schools still uncaught.
Monday, 18 July 2011
Golden Tate and NASCAR
How hard can it be to continuously turn left for a few hours? NASCAR is so simple that regular professional athletes could practice for a few months and immediately compete. What sort of talent does it require that makes it a sport?
That's what Golden Tate, wide receiver for the Seattle Seahawks, wants to know. Irritated that Jimmie Johnson was included in the ESPY's Best Male Athlete category, Tate took to Twitter to express is disapproval. His thoughts:
"Jimmy johnson up for best athlete???? Um nooo .. Driving a car does not show athleticism."
"I've driven a car on unknown roads at night at 90mph no big deal. No sign of athletism."
"Guarantee he couldn't in million year play any SPORT."
"I've driven a car on unknown roads at night at 90mph no big deal. No sign of athletism."
"Guarantee he couldn't in million year play any SPORT."
"give me 6 months of training and I bet I could compete."
Tate ultimately backed down after NASCAR supporters attacked him for his uneducated responses. But one couldn't help but feel like he only admitted defeat so as to stop the assaults. Johnson was a good sport about all of it, not striking back at Tate, but rather inviting him down to the track to spend a day racing with him.
Obviously this isn't a big story, but it does shed light on how many people feel about the debate over whether or not NASCAR drivers are athletes. And as much as it pains me, I am going to have to side with NASCAR supporters on this issue.
You wouldn't catch me dead watching a NASCAR race. I don't get it. At this point, it has developed into a cultural difference between the South and basically the rest of the country. Nothing about the sport interests me. But it is tough to completely dismiss when those stadiums routinely fill 250,000 seats for a six hour race, even if much of the excitement comes from tailgating beforehand.
But just because I don't have an interest in it doesn't mean that I don't have respect for the men and women who compete. Here are two big myths about NASCAR that I would argue are misconceptions about the sport and those involved in it:
NASCAR drivers are out of shape. They don't need the same kind of fitness or athleticism that other "real" athletes need.
Here's what you should do: go put on four layers of clothing; pants; socks; sweatshirts; and heavy boots. Then find a motorcycle helmet and put that on. If that isn't available, wrap your head in scarves and beanies to simulate the heat. Then go sit in a room with the temperature turned up to 120-130 degrees for the next five hours. I'll be the one waiting to call the ambulance from dehydration.
On average, a NASCAR driver loses 10 pounds during the course of a race. Logically, most of this is water weight because the racers aren't moving around to burn fat. But this certainly requires a special kind of training and fitness level. Sure, Golden Tate can run a 4.4 and has a vertical of over 30 inches. No way Jimmie Johnson can do that. But something tells me that Tate couldn't sit in a NASCAR vehicle that long, let alone race it, and come out alive. They can't dunk a basketball or hit a home run, but NASCAR drivers have trained and conditioned their bodies to perform a remarkable feat just like these other athletes.
All they do is drive a car. Turning left requires no skill.
You're right, turning left doesn't require skill. Turning left while driving a car at 190mph, on the other hand, definitely requires skill. Especially when you consider that these cars are within inches of each other throughout the course of a race. The amount of control, reflexes and coordination that these drivers demonstrate is a demonstration of athletic prowess in my mind. Just as a baseball player has to have the reflexes and control to hit a 95mph fastball, NASCAR racers have to negotiate between minuscule-sized spaces to pass their opponents. Driving on the Mass Pike is a nightmare. Passing other racers at the Daytona 500 is the 8th circle of Hell.
Whether or not you think a NASCAR driver is an athlete or not definitely depends on your definition of athletes. The same people who dismiss these drivers are probably those who fight against golfers, and maybe even some baseball players, claiming a title of "athlete." Perhaps I have a more liberal definition of "athlete" than most. But in my mind, there is little doubt that a man as accomplished and talented as Jimmie Johnson deserves the nomination he received.
Wednesday, 13 July 2011
James Harrison has hit his head a few too many times
With all those helmet-leading tackles, James Harrison appears to have truly lost it. Not that much doubt existed about this after his rant last year about how he simply wants to "hurt people" when he makes plays on the field. This time he fired off on Commissioner Goodell calling him a "crook," and a "devil," among other insults.
He also inexplicably attacked his quarterback, Ben Roethlisberger, and running back, Rashard Mendenhall. I'm not entirely sure why Harrison decided that now was the appropriate time to call out Big Ben for his Superbowl performance. Or why he felt that Mendenhall needed to be told that he has to do a better job not fumbling the ball (only two fumbles in 324 attempts in 2010). Both teammates claimed that they took no issue with what Harrison said about them, but I get the feeling that locker room stands at its whit's end from Harrison's motor mouth.
But the bigger part of this story is obviously his comments about Commissioner Goodell. The sad part about the whole situation is that Harrison actually made good points about the NFL's current safety policy with players. Unfortunately, because of all those body-crushing hits Harrison has laid across the league, he decided that an impassioned tirade, highlighted by the his declaration that if "[Commissioner Goodell] were on fire and [Harrison] had to piss to put him out, [Harrison] wouldn't," would be more effective than a calm and rational response.
Nobody should act surprised though. Calm and rational are words that have never been associated with Harrison. Immensely talented and a physical force no receiver or running back wants to cross, Harrison has failed once again to show control with his words.
James Harrison is in a position of unique power. He's definitely renowned, whether for positive or negative reasons, and with that notoriety comes a bigger pulpit to preach from. The press will pick up and run with what he says because of his history of outrageous comments and football skills. His criticisms of the NFL's policies are valid; but they aren't when he sounds like a raving lunatic discussing them.
Harrison may as fork over a portion of his paycheck each week from now on, because Roger Goodell isn't going to forget these comments. And he is exactly the type of man who would punish a player simply out of spite. Harrison didn't do anything to help labor negotiations through this interview. He probably didn't hurt them either. But he continues to damage his reputation, the team's, and the league's image in the eyes of the fans.
He also inexplicably attacked his quarterback, Ben Roethlisberger, and running back, Rashard Mendenhall. I'm not entirely sure why Harrison decided that now was the appropriate time to call out Big Ben for his Superbowl performance. Or why he felt that Mendenhall needed to be told that he has to do a better job not fumbling the ball (only two fumbles in 324 attempts in 2010). Both teammates claimed that they took no issue with what Harrison said about them, but I get the feeling that locker room stands at its whit's end from Harrison's motor mouth.
But the bigger part of this story is obviously his comments about Commissioner Goodell. The sad part about the whole situation is that Harrison actually made good points about the NFL's current safety policy with players. Unfortunately, because of all those body-crushing hits Harrison has laid across the league, he decided that an impassioned tirade, highlighted by the his declaration that if "[Commissioner Goodell] were on fire and [Harrison] had to piss to put him out, [Harrison] wouldn't," would be more effective than a calm and rational response.
Nobody should act surprised though. Calm and rational are words that have never been associated with Harrison. Immensely talented and a physical force no receiver or running back wants to cross, Harrison has failed once again to show control with his words.
James Harrison is in a position of unique power. He's definitely renowned, whether for positive or negative reasons, and with that notoriety comes a bigger pulpit to preach from. The press will pick up and run with what he says because of his history of outrageous comments and football skills. His criticisms of the NFL's policies are valid; but they aren't when he sounds like a raving lunatic discussing them.
Harrison may as fork over a portion of his paycheck each week from now on, because Roger Goodell isn't going to forget these comments. And he is exactly the type of man who would punish a player simply out of spite. Harrison didn't do anything to help labor negotiations through this interview. He probably didn't hurt them either. But he continues to damage his reputation, the team's, and the league's image in the eyes of the fans.
Monday, 11 July 2011
Thank goodness Jack Nicklaus is here!
As talk about the British Open begins to heat up, Jack Nicklaus, desperate to remain relevant, is here to make sure that we don't get too caught up with young Rory McIlroy. Jack just wants everyone to know that just because he won one major tournament does not mean that he is the new powerhouse golfer on the tour. Once he wins three or four or five tournaments, Jack says, then it is okay for those talks to start.
Alright, I admit that the number of articles that came out after the US Open christening McIlroy as the second coming of Tiger were awfully hasty. Clearly those writers forgot that the young Irishman had just blown a Sunday Masters lead in spectacular fashion merely a month before. But you know what? If those journalists want to sound like idiots, then that is their prerogative.
The last thing that we need is a washed-up golfer desperately trying to fend off any golfer that would threaten his status. This incident by itself would not bother me, but in combination with his decade-long attempt to trivialize Tiger's success, Jack doesn't exactly present himself as a likable character. Rory McIlroy is not the new superpower in golf yet. Any person who even remotely follows golf knows this. They are smart enough to ignore the sports writers who want to take any one moment and glorify it so vociferously that they actually ruin it.
Jack, we don't need you to tell us these things. And it certainly doesn't change anybody's opinion on the situation. Golf fans will believe either he is an anomaly or that he is a young, talented kid who has a long journey ahead of him. The last thing we need is an irrelevant spectator downplaying the accomplishments of current golfers.
Alright, I admit that the number of articles that came out after the US Open christening McIlroy as the second coming of Tiger were awfully hasty. Clearly those writers forgot that the young Irishman had just blown a Sunday Masters lead in spectacular fashion merely a month before. But you know what? If those journalists want to sound like idiots, then that is their prerogative.
The last thing that we need is a washed-up golfer desperately trying to fend off any golfer that would threaten his status. This incident by itself would not bother me, but in combination with his decade-long attempt to trivialize Tiger's success, Jack doesn't exactly present himself as a likable character. Rory McIlroy is not the new superpower in golf yet. Any person who even remotely follows golf knows this. They are smart enough to ignore the sports writers who want to take any one moment and glorify it so vociferously that they actually ruin it.
Jack, we don't need you to tell us these things. And it certainly doesn't change anybody's opinion on the situation. Golf fans will believe either he is an anomaly or that he is a young, talented kid who has a long journey ahead of him. The last thing we need is an irrelevant spectator downplaying the accomplishments of current golfers.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)