Showing posts with label Branding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Branding. Show all posts

Sunday, 7 September 2014

The Arby's Meat Mountain - A Well-Executed PR Campaign

Anyone who has been on the internet in the last two weeks has seen or heard about the new Arby's Meat Mountain - a Frankenstein concoction of greasy meats that would make even Joey Chestnut think twice before attacking it.

Seriously, look at that thing. I felt my heart skip a beat when I laid eyes on it. Image credit: CBS Chicago
















Arby's claimed that this off-the-menu item only became an internet phenomenon as more consumers stated hearing about it and demanding its official existence. That this would become an organic request from customers isn't an entirely shocking way for the Meat Mountain to be put on the menu. When I worked at Jamba Juice, there were so many "secret" smoothies that customers would order that we ultimately had official recipes for all of them. I would go to random Jamba's around Portland to see if I could get the same ones and, sure enough, they all made them the same way. 

With this in mind, it wouldn't shock me if this was something that a few customers asked for, told their friends about and unintentionally started a grassroots effort to make the Meat Mountain an official Arby's sandwich. Customer is always right in the service industry, right?

Slate's L.V. Anderson didn't seem to think that this was an organic request from consumers, but, rather, a well-orchestrated PR campaign from Arby's that the company planted in a few strategic areas and watched the story go viral. She essentially concludes that it does look like that there was some organic demand for the sandwich, but that Arby's likely played a big part in pushing it forward.

Going off that premise, this is one hell of a job from the Arby's PR team. I am willing to bet that they heard from a few stores that said customers were requesting this and they saw an opportunity to turn it into a full-blown campaign. Landing pieces in major outlets across the country over a two week period is the definition of viral. The sandwich had its own hashtag on Twitter for a day or two.

Companies are always looking to take a campaign or story viral. It is enough to make a PR person's eyes roll so hard that they freeze. That response is generally warranted because what it takes for a story to go viral these days is still a bit of a mystery. There are certain elements of a viral campaign that will be essential for companies to have in place, but, at the end of the day, if customers don't take up the cause then the campaign will fall flat on its face. A lot of times it is dumb luck what catches on and what doesn't. But a company can help propel a campaign to viral status if it takes off with the public initially.

Arby's executed particularly well on a couple of tactics that helped the Meat Mountain really explode. First, they let the customers have control of the creation. As a consumer, if I hear that this product is being pushed solely by the company, it's motivations are obvious - sales and greater revenue. But since this demand and request for the sandwich came from the consumer and Arby's then gave in and added it to the menu, it gave it authenticity that wouldn't have existed from a traditional introduction. Putting the power in the hands of the consumer is a risky strategy, but it can pay huge dividends ultimately.

Second, Arby's let the buzz build for a while before it really addressed the sandwich. The company was fairly mum on it when it first started appearing across social channels and eyes slowly started turning towards them on when they would officially respond. Arby's timed its response well and extended the news cycle around the sandwich, which is no small feat when we're talking about fast food.

Third, they played the hero by giving the customer what they wanted. Obviously Arby's had to do cost-profit analysis to make sure that this sandwich made sense for them, but that's not how it is presented when the company "gives in" to the consumer demand. It demonstrates that the company values its customer base's opinion and is committed to making the sandwiches that they want to eat, gimmicky or not.

Sure, this campaign was a little too smooth and effective to have simply been organically created, but who cares? Arby's PR team should treat themselves to a steak dinner to celebrate because they earned it.

Monday, 1 September 2014

Nike Just Made Kevin Durant A Very, Very Rich Man

Can't blame Under Armour for the attempt, at least.

The company offered Kevin Durant a ten year deal that would pay him more than $260 million dollars over that time in an effort to steal away one of the most valuable pieces of Nike's army of athletes. Unfortunately for Under Armour, Nike had a clause in Durant's original contract that would allow them to match any offer from a competitor. I sure hope that lawyer who included that clause in the contract got a nice bonus as a result.

Nike, unsurprisingly, decided to match the offer. While Under Armour bet the house by going after Durant, resigning him was an absolute no-brainer for Nike. Under Armour is certainly going to make Nike pay a little more than it was hoping - reports were that Nike offered an initial deal that would pay Durant only $20 million - the Swoosh really only had one choice in the situation.

Some experts speculated that the steep price may keep Nike from resigning Durant. They already boast the biggest collection of valuable marketing assets in the world when it comes to basketball, so if they had to let one go, it wouldn't be the end of the world. But Nike is smart enough to know that while shelling out a little extra money may hurt the bottom line at the end of the day, keeping the third most recognizable basketball player in the world (LeBron and Kobe being #1 & #2, respectively) under their contract and not a major competitor like Under Armour is critical for future success.

Under Armour is trying to break into the basketball market that long has been held by Nike and Adidas. It recently picked up Steph Curry as an endorser, but it knows that it needs to land a whale in order to really make a splash. That's why the aggressive move to go after Durant made sense. It would give them immediate credibility and open up the company to greater international reach, somewhere where the company has lagged behind Nike and Adidas, especially in basketball.

But I would not be surprised if Nike was prepared months earlier for a massive bid and simply needed to see exactly how much it would cost the company. Because at the end of the day, this really won't cost Nike too much. Durant's signature shoes fly off the shelves. As long as he continues to perform at the same level he has, which following an unbelievable MVP season isn't unlikely, those shoes will keep selling and Nike will keep stacking cash.

Sure, $300 million is no small amount. But Nike has proven time and time again that it makes the most out of every single dollar it puts into sponsorships. The company's marketing panache practically ensures that they'll get ridiculous ROI from Durant. And, perhaps more importantly, it's left a competitor empty-handed and pondering the next big move it must make to take on the king.

Wednesday, 18 June 2014

Another Day, Another Social Media Screw-up - Delta Airlines Edition

I have taken a look at some pretty terrible social media screw-ups on my blog in the past and every time I write about it, I always think to myself that it has to be the last time that we will see a major brand botch it badly. Enough articles outlining various social media failures exist at this point that we could create an entire Encyclopedia Britannica of what not to do when engaging with the public on social media.

But, thankfully for us, and much to the chagrin of communications managers everywhere, companies like Delta Airlines still exist and somehow find new ways to remind us that social media is always just a little more complicated than it needs to be.

After the US beat Ghana 2-1 on Monday night, Delta decided that this was an appropriate tweet to send out:

Twitter quickly pointed out that there are, in fact, no giraffes in Ghana. This issue could have been solved if the social media team had taken a collective thirty seconds to Google whether or not giraffes were in the country. Here, let me do it for you.

Sure, everyone wants to be part of discussions on current events. We get that and accept that it must be done. But if you are going to do it, then why stray from the safest possible tweet?

The team should have stopped and asked themselves several questions:
  • Will adding the image enhance the tweet in any way? 
I know that tweets with images are more engaged with on Twitter, but did Delta really think that would be the case here? Legitimate question - how is this tweet improved with an image? You can't add an image to a tweet every time and expect it to be better. Show some discretion and pick your spots.
  • Okay, let's go with an image. What two images represent these countries? 
Gee, I don't know, what is arguably the biggest thing that the average person uses to identify foreign countries? A flag. The country's flag. Why are you making this harder than it needs to be? You don't stand to gain anything really by being part of this, but you sure as heck stand to lose by doing it incorrectly.
  • Why are we selecting these images?
Again, a question so simple and, yet, nobody seemed to have asked it. Because if they had, the group would have Googled whether giraffes are in Ghana and decided to go a different route.

If you clearly don't have your ducks in a row, sometimes it is better to just sit a few plays out than put yourself in a potentially compromising position. And that's a lesson that Delta is learning the hard way.

Monday, 2 June 2014

Stop Screwing Up Social Media - It's Just Not That Hard

"I know what will really inspire our brand ambassadors," said generic social media "expert" at large corporation. "We need to give them something that they can tag themselves with and declare their loyalty to our company in an effort to convert others to our services. What we need to do is give them a hashtag on Twitter!"

"Dead on!" replied slightly more junior social media "expert." "This way the people can simply send out a Tweet and all of those around them will see how dedicated they are to us and our community will grow!"

You know I would have thought that this conversation stopped taking place several years ago given how obvious it is that:

  • It is a lazy comms strategy
  • Personal testimony over Twitter is simply a one-time act - not likely to occur again outside the one time the hashtag is created
  • Any brand that could have alienated its users at some point has now given control to those users by opening up the world of social media to the conversation
McDonalds screwed this one up pretty badly when it invited everyone to share their #McDStories (gee, wonder what could have possibly gone wrong with that one?). J.P. Morgan also blew it with their chat to #AskJPM a question, leading to a hilarious series of tweets asking how one goes about blowing up the global economy as effectively as J.P. Morgan helped do. Roger Goodell is no stranger to controversy with how the NFL has handled the lawsuits that former NFL players are bringing in droves that accuse the league of knowingly withholding information on the dangers of playing football, all while trying to add an additional regular season and playoff game to the mix for some more cash for the league. So maybe it wasn't the best idea to give fans (and players) an open forum to #AskCommish anything they thought was important.

#AskEmmert with the NCAA's embattled commissioner Mark Emmert was hijacked. So was #RedskinsPride - the Washington Redskins effort to combat Harry Reid's crusade to force the team to change its name. 

Even what should have been a safe #ILoveWalgreens hashtag was taken over by an unruly social media mob. If your neighborhood drug store isn't a sure bet, don't you think that that might be a sign?

These are all very high-profile businesses here that are really screwing up a comms tactic that isn't that hard. And the reason it isn't that hard is because you just don't do it. I can't think of any time, any brand, in any part of the world that wouldn't run the risk of getting taken over like those mentioned earlier.

I'm not saying don't engage with fans on social media. But the hashtag pride strategy needs to stop. Control the forum and you can help control the message. Send it into the wild and your Twitter hashtag will mutate into an uncontrollable beast.

Wednesday, 16 April 2014

The White House Social Media Policy: Is Ray-Ban Really Different From Samsung?

A few weeks back, the Boston Red Sox visited the White House to meet with the President because the team won the 2013 World Series. David Ortiz snapped a selfie with Obama and posted it to his Twitter feed, garnering thousands of favorites and retweets. A few days later, it came out that the selfie loosely came as a result of a newly signed sponsorship deal Ortiz had just started with Samsung. Lots of people threw hissy fits about marketing, advertising, authenticity, etc.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney was quoted saying "As a rule, the White House objects to attempts to use the president's likeness for commercial purposes. And we certainly object in this case."

Two weeks later, a funny thing happened involving the White House once again (albeit, not with President Obama this time). Vice President Joe Biden joined the Instagram community today and his first photo looks awfully promotional, doesn't it:


For all of the ire that the Ortiz-Obama selfie drew, the reaction around the Biden Instagram photo is quite different. Time called the photo "utter perfection." Business Insider said that it was "incredibly on brand." Buzzfeed said his "'gram game is perfect Biden.

Sure, there are some differences between the two photos. Biden posted it himself. Obama did not. Biden was aware of the purpose behind the image. Obama was not.

But if you are going off of Carney's statement above as a general rule of thumb - and it is not an unreasonable assumption that the White House doesn't want the VP used for commercial purposes - explain to me how this is not commercial. Yeah, Biden wears Ray-Bans all the time and it is a trademark of his. But isn't a trademark of Obama being a fun guy who would participate in a selfie with a jubilant David Ortiz anyway? The tweet didn't even mention anything about Samsung, nor would your first thought be "oh, that's a Samsung Galaxy 5 in Ortiz's hand!!" That couldn't have been any less in-your-face branding.

Meanwhile, the Biden/Ray-Ban photo looks like it was taken straight from a final cut of advertisements for the company. It couldn't be any more promotional if it tried.

I understand that the White House would like to control the likeness of the President and Vice President to avoid any unknowing promotional purposes. But this does seem a little off, doesn't it? The White House shouldn't get to pick and choose when it is promotional, whether intentionally or not.

Wednesday, 2 April 2014

David Ortiz and Samsung Challenge Authenticity with White House Selfie

The Boston Red Sox visited the White House on Tuesday as the reigning World Series Champions. The tradition of inviting the winning team of a professional sports league or national championship for college is a little cliche at this point, but I think I am just saying that because none of my teams have ever had the opportunity to visit the POTUS. Regardless, it makes for an easy day for the media to post a couple of pictures and generic athlete quotes about how happy they are to be there, slap it together and there is your story (or lack there of).

David Ortiz decided to spice things up a bit at the White House visit by grabbing a hilarious selfie with Obama and tweeting it out. It has picked up almost 40,000 retweets and more than 45,000 favorites. Everyone had a good laugh about it, it added a little more color to the "story" of the Red Sox visit and then we continue to live our lives normally.

Today it came out that Samsung was up to its old Oscars tricks again and that this was a planned selfie by Ortiz  that Obama did not actually know about beforehand. Okay, whatever. It is still a funny tweet and a good reminder that both professional athletes and the President are human beings with senses of humor. There wasn't any promotional branding in the tweet that suggested Samsung was behind this and it wasn't screaming at me to go buy a Galaxy or Note.

Well, I guess that not everyone felt the same way about it...

"Hang on. Did Samsung really use the word ‘genuine’ in its response? The moment was about as bona fide as the Grade A meat in Hot Pockets. I mean, if there is indeed any purpose of the "selfie," it’s about capturing something impromptu." - Eric Wilbur, Boston.com

"Spontaneity is dead. Samsung killed it." - Chris Cillizza, Washington Post

"Duping the president of the United States into participating with your social media campaign has to be anew low for advertising. It’s flat-out shady. And Ortiz should be embarrassed." - Joshua Green, Bloomberg

Holy shit, these are serious quotes about this? I can't actually believe that people would get this upset about it. Here's a question for them - does you think that because Ortiz did this because Samsung asked him to that it made his smile, his excitement and everything associated with the picture any less sincere? If you honestly think that, then your cynicism has reached an unhealthy height.

As I said above, Samsung wasn't in-your-face about the tweet. They didn't ask Ortiz to use any promotional branding and Ortiz didn't try to force it in there either. Sure, it is an old trick and not a terribly creative one (although, it does raise the sentiment of 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it'). But I don't feel duped by Samsung because of it. When I look at that picture, I see a professional athlete who is an idol to thousands of people with a smile that is ear to ear as he is with someone who is actually more recognizable than he is in public.

So I would highly recommend to anyone who is upset by this to just stop and reevaluate what is worth getting irritated about these days. Because a hilarious picture that came about of a corporate sponsorship should not be high on the list of righteous indignation triggers.

Sidenote: When has a selfie EVER been impromptu? I would argue that a selfie is honestly as far from an impromptu action as they come. For the love of god, and I hate to even have to point to the song "Selfie" but if that doesn't show that they are as calculated as they come, then I don't know what does. Please, don't age yourself like that Boston.com.
















Tuesday, 1 April 2014

Care.com & The NYSE: Humanize The Brand

In January of this year, Care.com listed its initial public offering on the New York Stock Exchange. Care.com is a basically an e-commerce website for baby-sitters. Rather than dealing with word-of-mouth referrals or asking your niece or nephew who may not know how to boil a pot of water, Care.com gives parents a chance to scope out their baby-sitter ahead of time. The industry of full-time nannies and dedicated baby-sitters is booming and Care.com jumped on it early, making the lives of parents easier and more assured.

While watching major cable news networks over the last couple of weeks, I have noticed the commercial where Care.com's CEO, Sheila Marcelo, is ringing the opening bell of the NYSE on the day of the company's IPO. The advertisement can be seen here. Essentially, Marcelo is talking about how happy she is that Care.com has been such a success, how she is living the American dream, etc. It is definitely a great story, especially given that probably not very many people would have thought that she could have taken this company public when she first came up with the idea.

The story is all well and good, but the interesting thing to me in this advertisement is that it is actually a NYSE advertisement. The closing image is of the NYSE logo, but the whole focus is on Care.com.

So why is this significant?

Listen carefully to the messaging that Marcelo uses when she is talking. Love, caring, live, reliable, perfect. Those are all words that Marcelo and Care.com wants associated with their brand for obvious reasons. But the NYSE wants to draw off of that positivity of the Care.com mantra, whether that is explicitly stated or not. The association factor is key here for the NYSE as - let's be honest here - nobody will use any of the above adjectives to describe its brand.

The finance industry is still suffering an image issue following the financial crisis of the past few years. By highlighting the success of a company like Care.com, with a founder who even describes herself as "living the American dream", the NYSE humanizes its brand. It helps dispel the myth that anyone involved in the process is a white male in a stiff suit who only cares about tax breaks and bigger dividends.

Care.com and the NYSE is a natural pairing from a branding perspective in this regard. Both have something to gain - Care.com gets great national exposure, particularly to a more affluent audience that will help generate greater revenue and the NYSE gets to highlight a lovable brand with a founder who is the antithesis of the public's perception of the exchange.

It may be subtle, but I think that both come out ahead in this instance. It isn't going to dispel the belief that the stock exchange is the epitome of greed, but it is one smart step in that direction.