Following Bubba Watston's second Master's victory in three years, I fired up Twitter to see what people had to say about the conclusion. One particular tweet from Bomani Jones caught my eye and it was actually about Jordan Spieth, who finished three strokes behind Watson and tied with Jonas Blixt for second. Spieth is a 20 year-old on the PGA Tour who was nipping at Watson's heels all day. He was one missed birdie put on 16 to cut Watson's lead to two with two holes to play and put a little pressure on him.
Needless to say, it was an amazing performance from the young man and we should expect to see him competing at a high level for many years.
But the tweet stood out to me because of how the individual commented on Spieth's play to address an issue in another sport:
"anyone think golf needs a rule requiring players to stay in school for three years? or that only apply to sports that you like to watch?"
My first thought here was that Jones was talking about the NBA where the age limitation has always been a hot-button issue for the league. But that only requires individuals to be one year outside of high school in order to enter the draft. The only sport that requires three years is the NFL.
I'm not totally sure what Jones is going for with his tweet, to be honest. But it sounds like he is suggesting that the rule for making college football players be three years removed from high school is detrimental to the league/players. I hope that isn't the case, because that just wouldn't make sense.
Say what you will about the NBA's age limit, but the NFL's is a necessity from a very basic level - it makes athletes take a few years to continue growing, becoming bigger, faster, and stronger to take on guys who may be more than 10 years their senior. The NFL has an age limit because if it didn't, then college students going any earlier would get seriously hurt. And I just don't think that there is any question about that.
To suggest that there could be a discussion around abolishing the age requirement for the NFL is absurd at best. There is no chance of an 18 year-old golfer getting hurt playing with men twice his age. It is almost a guarantee that an 18 year-old football player would get hurt by a man twice his size due to the extra years he has had to develop.
The argument isn't just apples to oranges. Its just straight bananas.
Sports, public relations and impassioned rants throughout. Commentary from the peanut gallery is encouraged.
Sunday, 13 April 2014
Wednesday, 2 April 2014
David Ortiz and Samsung Challenge Authenticity with White House Selfie
The Boston Red Sox visited the White House on Tuesday as the reigning World Series Champions. The tradition of inviting the winning team of a professional sports league or national championship for college is a little cliche at this point, but I think I am just saying that because none of my teams have ever had the opportunity to visit the POTUS. Regardless, it makes for an easy day for the media to post a couple of pictures and generic athlete quotes about how happy they are to be there, slap it together and there is your story (or lack there of).
David Ortiz decided to spice things up a bit at the White House visit by grabbing a hilarious selfie with Obama and tweeting it out. It has picked up almost 40,000 retweets and more than 45,000 favorites. Everyone had a good laugh about it, it added a little more color to the "story" of the Red Sox visit and then we continue to live our lives normally.
Today it came out that Samsung was up to its old Oscars tricks again and that this was a planned selfie by Ortiz that Obama did not actually know about beforehand. Okay, whatever. It is still a funny tweet and a good reminder that both professional athletes and the President are human beings with senses of humor. There wasn't any promotional branding in the tweet that suggested Samsung was behind this and it wasn't screaming at me to go buy a Galaxy or Note.
Well, I guess that not everyone felt the same way about it...
"Hang on. Did Samsung really use the word ‘genuine’ in its response? The moment was about as bona fide as the Grade A meat in Hot Pockets. I mean, if there is indeed any purpose of the "selfie," it’s about capturing something impromptu." - Eric Wilbur, Boston.com
"Spontaneity is dead. Samsung killed it." - Chris Cillizza, Washington Post
"Duping the president of the United States into participating with your social media campaign has to be anew low for advertising. It’s flat-out shady. And Ortiz should be embarrassed." - Joshua Green, Bloomberg
Holy shit, these are serious quotes about this? I can't actually believe that people would get this upset about it. Here's a question for them - does you think that because Ortiz did this because Samsung asked him to that it made his smile, his excitement and everything associated with the picture any less sincere? If you honestly think that, then your cynicism has reached an unhealthy height.
As I said above, Samsung wasn't in-your-face about the tweet. They didn't ask Ortiz to use any promotional branding and Ortiz didn't try to force it in there either. Sure, it is an old trick and not a terribly creative one (although, it does raise the sentiment of 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it'). But I don't feel duped by Samsung because of it. When I look at that picture, I see a professional athlete who is an idol to thousands of people with a smile that is ear to ear as he is with someone who is actually more recognizable than he is in public.
So I would highly recommend to anyone who is upset by this to just stop and reevaluate what is worth getting irritated about these days. Because a hilarious picture that came about of a corporate sponsorship should not be high on the list of righteous indignation triggers.
Sidenote: When has a selfie EVER been impromptu? I would argue that a selfie is honestly as far from an impromptu action as they come. For the love of god, and I hate to even have to point to the song "Selfie" but if that doesn't show that they are as calculated as they come, then I don't know what does. Please, don't age yourself like that Boston.com.
David Ortiz decided to spice things up a bit at the White House visit by grabbing a hilarious selfie with Obama and tweeting it out. It has picked up almost 40,000 retweets and more than 45,000 favorites. Everyone had a good laugh about it, it added a little more color to the "story" of the Red Sox visit and then we continue to live our lives normally.
Today it came out that Samsung was up to its old Oscars tricks again and that this was a planned selfie by Ortiz that Obama did not actually know about beforehand. Okay, whatever. It is still a funny tweet and a good reminder that both professional athletes and the President are human beings with senses of humor. There wasn't any promotional branding in the tweet that suggested Samsung was behind this and it wasn't screaming at me to go buy a Galaxy or Note.
Well, I guess that not everyone felt the same way about it...
"Hang on. Did Samsung really use the word ‘genuine’ in its response? The moment was about as bona fide as the Grade A meat in Hot Pockets. I mean, if there is indeed any purpose of the "selfie," it’s about capturing something impromptu." - Eric Wilbur, Boston.com
"Spontaneity is dead. Samsung killed it." - Chris Cillizza, Washington Post
"Duping the president of the United States into participating with your social media campaign has to be anew low for advertising. It’s flat-out shady. And Ortiz should be embarrassed." - Joshua Green, Bloomberg
Holy shit, these are serious quotes about this? I can't actually believe that people would get this upset about it. Here's a question for them - does you think that because Ortiz did this because Samsung asked him to that it made his smile, his excitement and everything associated with the picture any less sincere? If you honestly think that, then your cynicism has reached an unhealthy height.
As I said above, Samsung wasn't in-your-face about the tweet. They didn't ask Ortiz to use any promotional branding and Ortiz didn't try to force it in there either. Sure, it is an old trick and not a terribly creative one (although, it does raise the sentiment of 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it'). But I don't feel duped by Samsung because of it. When I look at that picture, I see a professional athlete who is an idol to thousands of people with a smile that is ear to ear as he is with someone who is actually more recognizable than he is in public.
So I would highly recommend to anyone who is upset by this to just stop and reevaluate what is worth getting irritated about these days. Because a hilarious picture that came about of a corporate sponsorship should not be high on the list of righteous indignation triggers.
Sidenote: When has a selfie EVER been impromptu? I would argue that a selfie is honestly as far from an impromptu action as they come. For the love of god, and I hate to even have to point to the song "Selfie" but if that doesn't show that they are as calculated as they come, then I don't know what does. Please, don't age yourself like that Boston.com.
Tuesday, 1 April 2014
Care.com & The NYSE: Humanize The Brand
In January of this year, Care.com listed its initial public offering on the New York Stock Exchange. Care.com is a basically an e-commerce website for baby-sitters. Rather than dealing with word-of-mouth referrals or asking your niece or nephew who may not know how to boil a pot of water, Care.com gives parents a chance to scope out their baby-sitter ahead of time. The industry of full-time nannies and dedicated baby-sitters is booming and Care.com jumped on it early, making the lives of parents easier and more assured.
While watching major cable news networks over the last couple of weeks, I have noticed the commercial where Care.com's CEO, Sheila Marcelo, is ringing the opening bell of the NYSE on the day of the company's IPO. The advertisement can be seen here. Essentially, Marcelo is talking about how happy she is that Care.com has been such a success, how she is living the American dream, etc. It is definitely a great story, especially given that probably not very many people would have thought that she could have taken this company public when she first came up with the idea.
The story is all well and good, but the interesting thing to me in this advertisement is that it is actually a NYSE advertisement. The closing image is of the NYSE logo, but the whole focus is on Care.com.
So why is this significant?
Listen carefully to the messaging that Marcelo uses when she is talking. Love, caring, live, reliable, perfect. Those are all words that Marcelo and Care.com wants associated with their brand for obvious reasons. But the NYSE wants to draw off of that positivity of the Care.com mantra, whether that is explicitly stated or not. The association factor is key here for the NYSE as - let's be honest here - nobody will use any of the above adjectives to describe its brand.
The finance industry is still suffering an image issue following the financial crisis of the past few years. By highlighting the success of a company like Care.com, with a founder who even describes herself as "living the American dream", the NYSE humanizes its brand. It helps dispel the myth that anyone involved in the process is a white male in a stiff suit who only cares about tax breaks and bigger dividends.
Care.com and the NYSE is a natural pairing from a branding perspective in this regard. Both have something to gain - Care.com gets great national exposure, particularly to a more affluent audience that will help generate greater revenue and the NYSE gets to highlight a lovable brand with a founder who is the antithesis of the public's perception of the exchange.
It may be subtle, but I think that both come out ahead in this instance. It isn't going to dispel the belief that the stock exchange is the epitome of greed, but it is one smart step in that direction.
While watching major cable news networks over the last couple of weeks, I have noticed the commercial where Care.com's CEO, Sheila Marcelo, is ringing the opening bell of the NYSE on the day of the company's IPO. The advertisement can be seen here. Essentially, Marcelo is talking about how happy she is that Care.com has been such a success, how she is living the American dream, etc. It is definitely a great story, especially given that probably not very many people would have thought that she could have taken this company public when she first came up with the idea.
The story is all well and good, but the interesting thing to me in this advertisement is that it is actually a NYSE advertisement. The closing image is of the NYSE logo, but the whole focus is on Care.com.
So why is this significant?
Listen carefully to the messaging that Marcelo uses when she is talking. Love, caring, live, reliable, perfect. Those are all words that Marcelo and Care.com wants associated with their brand for obvious reasons. But the NYSE wants to draw off of that positivity of the Care.com mantra, whether that is explicitly stated or not. The association factor is key here for the NYSE as - let's be honest here - nobody will use any of the above adjectives to describe its brand.
The finance industry is still suffering an image issue following the financial crisis of the past few years. By highlighting the success of a company like Care.com, with a founder who even describes herself as "living the American dream", the NYSE humanizes its brand. It helps dispel the myth that anyone involved in the process is a white male in a stiff suit who only cares about tax breaks and bigger dividends.
Care.com and the NYSE is a natural pairing from a branding perspective in this regard. Both have something to gain - Care.com gets great national exposure, particularly to a more affluent audience that will help generate greater revenue and the NYSE gets to highlight a lovable brand with a founder who is the antithesis of the public's perception of the exchange.
It may be subtle, but I think that both come out ahead in this instance. It isn't going to dispel the belief that the stock exchange is the epitome of greed, but it is one smart step in that direction.
Sunday, 23 February 2014
Greg Oden & Anthony Bennett - How We Lose Perspective
Greg Oden started in his first NBA game since 2009 when he broke his kneecap playing for the Portland Trail Blazers. He had already suffered micro-knee fracture surgery and would undergo the same surgery two more times in the next three years. Needless to say, it was a less than ideal start for Oden who was drawing comparisons to Hakeem and Patrick Ewing upon entering the league.
Anthony Bennett, who the Cleveland Cavaliers drafted number one overall in 2013, hasn't exactly lived up to the expectations that come with being the top draft pick. Bennett was definitely a surprise and didn't have the hype around him that Oden did when he entered the league, but that doesn't make the scrutiny around him disappear.
Is Greg Oden a disappointment? What about Anthony Bennett? Did the Blazers and the Cavs completely screw up those draft picks? How can one player get injured all the time? How come the other just isn't as talented as we all thought he was?
Both players are complete busts.
I've seen those words written about both players (more notably for Oden given the aforementioned expectations) with shocking frequency. It doesn't come as a shock that these conversations take place given our affinity for professional sports and the enormous media landscape behind it. When you look at it from the perspective of a sports fan, it is a completely fair discussion.
But what about when we take a step back and think of these young men (don't forget just how young they really are) as just employees for a business? This is their job and they do absolutely everything that they can to get back on track. I don't think that either Oden or Bennett give anything less than 100% when it comes to their profession.
When I think of it as a job, not just two guys who are playing a sport, it saddens me quite a bit to see how much pleasure some people get out of their struggles. Imagine if the next time you were at the office and you messed up on a project, you saw people exchanging emails about what a screw-up you were. People snickering when they find out that you've hit another bump.
I recognize that this is comparing apples and oranges a little bit. And I am not saying that their performance can't be examined closely. But there is no denying that at the end of the day, we expect to be treated with respect from our coworkers and peers with respect to our jobs, just like we should treat them with the same respect. And part of that is not hoping for their failure because it amuses us.
Greg Oden finished with five points and five rebounds today. Anthony Bennett finished with four points and four rebounds. But I'm pulling hard for both of them. They're doing their jobs and deserve more respect than they get. Because we expect the same for us.
Anthony Bennett, who the Cleveland Cavaliers drafted number one overall in 2013, hasn't exactly lived up to the expectations that come with being the top draft pick. Bennett was definitely a surprise and didn't have the hype around him that Oden did when he entered the league, but that doesn't make the scrutiny around him disappear.
Is Greg Oden a disappointment? What about Anthony Bennett? Did the Blazers and the Cavs completely screw up those draft picks? How can one player get injured all the time? How come the other just isn't as talented as we all thought he was?
Both players are complete busts.
I've seen those words written about both players (more notably for Oden given the aforementioned expectations) with shocking frequency. It doesn't come as a shock that these conversations take place given our affinity for professional sports and the enormous media landscape behind it. When you look at it from the perspective of a sports fan, it is a completely fair discussion.
But what about when we take a step back and think of these young men (don't forget just how young they really are) as just employees for a business? This is their job and they do absolutely everything that they can to get back on track. I don't think that either Oden or Bennett give anything less than 100% when it comes to their profession.
When I think of it as a job, not just two guys who are playing a sport, it saddens me quite a bit to see how much pleasure some people get out of their struggles. Imagine if the next time you were at the office and you messed up on a project, you saw people exchanging emails about what a screw-up you were. People snickering when they find out that you've hit another bump.
I recognize that this is comparing apples and oranges a little bit. And I am not saying that their performance can't be examined closely. But there is no denying that at the end of the day, we expect to be treated with respect from our coworkers and peers with respect to our jobs, just like we should treat them with the same respect. And part of that is not hoping for their failure because it amuses us.
Greg Oden finished with five points and five rebounds today. Anthony Bennett finished with four points and four rebounds. But I'm pulling hard for both of them. They're doing their jobs and deserve more respect than they get. Because we expect the same for us.
Monday, 17 February 2014
My NBA Mount Rushmore
One of the big conversations around the NBA All-Star game this year was who would be the four players on your Mount Rushmore of basketball. I certainly didn't want to be left out of the conversation, so here are my thoughts for the four faces that make their way onto the iconic rock:
Who would be in your Mount Rushmore of NBA players?
- Michael Jordan
- Could this one be any more obvious? The man IS the NBA in so many ways. 50 years from now, we will still be talking about the shrug, the flu game, the shot and the push-off (depends on who you ask). With any luck, we'll have burned any records that remind us that he is one of the worst executives in NBA history.
- Larry Bird
- 3x NBA champ, 3x MVP, 9x 1st team All NBA and a whole bunch of other accolades that aren't worth listing out because it would take way too much time. Tough as nails, but with a shooting touch as soft as fresh sheets in the summertime. Plus, you're telling me his face wouldn't look great chiseled out in rock?
- Oscar Robertson
- The man revolutionized the point guard position. He is the only player in NBA history to average a triple-double for an entire season. I don't care if the pace of play was insanely high that year; averaging a triple double over the course of 82 games is something we might not ever see again.
- Tim Duncan
- Yeah, okay, so maybe I am biased because he is the best player that I can remember watching the entire duration of his career. But his statistics, consistency and team's relevancy for his time in the league is nearly unmatched. Timmy D may not be the sexiest player in NBA history, but he is damn sure one of the best. As a sidenote, there would be some construction issues trying to make his eyes pop out like they do when he is upset about a call.
Who would be in your Mount Rushmore of NBA players?
Is LeBron James against supporting the troops? No. Just stop.
Following Saturday's seriously climactic finish of USA vs. Russia in hockey, where TJ Oshie rightfully became a household name after willing the US to victory in a shootout, fans were treated to a great post-game interview. Hockey players make for some of the best interviews in my opinion because most of them have clearly not had media training and seem to genuinely love what they do.
TJ Oshie is no different. He said all of the right things in several interviews - the thanks should go to US goalie Jonathan Quick, this was really a solid team effort, forecheck, forecheck and forecheck some more - and, of course, in what has become a strange motif of all sporting interviews, Oshie brushes off the title of hero and says that "the American heroes are wearing camo."
Nobody doubts that our American soldiers, whether overseas or based here in the US, are truly heroes for which we all owe great thanks. Athletes, in particular, have become rather fond of praising the troops whenever the opportunity arises. Great! The more appreciation and recognition, the better.
Then a curious thing started happening. This meme started to make its way around Facebook:
You know what, I don't even have the time to sit here and pretend to be diplomatic about this. If you liked this meme on Facebook, retweeted it, shared it on Instagram or whatever form of social media you used - you are dumber than a lobotomized pig and I think less of you.
You're totally right - LeBron is definitely against the troops and is completely selfish for saying that he likes being seen as a role model. Anyone who embraces that fact and is cognizant that it affects his actions on and off the court clearly cares about nobody but himself. No, that makes plenty of sense. I mean, how DARE he suggest that he can serve as a level to aspire to for kids and adults of any age. Coupled with the audacity of not showing love for the troops? ASSHOLE.
Seriously, though, can someone please explain this to me? Why are we trying to vilify LeBron here? It's not like he does about 45x (at LEAST) the number of interviews that TJ Oshie does on a yearly basis and has almost certainly given his thanks to the troops at some point.
Oh, wait. Yes, he has - LeBron James does right by troops. Thank you, internet archives, for allowing me to Google that in approximately 10 seconds and post it to show just how truly idiotic people are for making this comparison.
Supporting the troops is a given. Saying it in every single interview is not a requirement. Especially for a guy who is interviewed multiple times a week.
And promoting bull shit memes like this perpetuates the stereotype of the self-absorbed, thinks-he's-the-greatest-of-all-time black athlete and nobody should stand for it.
LeBron James is a hero to millions of people around the world for his works on and off the court. TJ Oshie is a hero to so many patriots in this country who feel that the Olympics stand for something more than just sports. And the troops that support us are certainly heroes as well - a fact that barely needs repeating at this point.
It's great to remind ourselves that there isn't just one type of heroes in this world.
TJ Oshie is no different. He said all of the right things in several interviews - the thanks should go to US goalie Jonathan Quick, this was really a solid team effort, forecheck, forecheck and forecheck some more - and, of course, in what has become a strange motif of all sporting interviews, Oshie brushes off the title of hero and says that "the American heroes are wearing camo."
Nobody doubts that our American soldiers, whether overseas or based here in the US, are truly heroes for which we all owe great thanks. Athletes, in particular, have become rather fond of praising the troops whenever the opportunity arises. Great! The more appreciation and recognition, the better.
Then a curious thing started happening. This meme started to make its way around Facebook:
You know what, I don't even have the time to sit here and pretend to be diplomatic about this. If you liked this meme on Facebook, retweeted it, shared it on Instagram or whatever form of social media you used - you are dumber than a lobotomized pig and I think less of you.
You're totally right - LeBron is definitely against the troops and is completely selfish for saying that he likes being seen as a role model. Anyone who embraces that fact and is cognizant that it affects his actions on and off the court clearly cares about nobody but himself. No, that makes plenty of sense. I mean, how DARE he suggest that he can serve as a level to aspire to for kids and adults of any age. Coupled with the audacity of not showing love for the troops? ASSHOLE.
Seriously, though, can someone please explain this to me? Why are we trying to vilify LeBron here? It's not like he does about 45x (at LEAST) the number of interviews that TJ Oshie does on a yearly basis and has almost certainly given his thanks to the troops at some point.
Oh, wait. Yes, he has - LeBron James does right by troops. Thank you, internet archives, for allowing me to Google that in approximately 10 seconds and post it to show just how truly idiotic people are for making this comparison.
Supporting the troops is a given. Saying it in every single interview is not a requirement. Especially for a guy who is interviewed multiple times a week.
And promoting bull shit memes like this perpetuates the stereotype of the self-absorbed, thinks-he's-the-greatest-of-all-time black athlete and nobody should stand for it.
LeBron James is a hero to millions of people around the world for his works on and off the court. TJ Oshie is a hero to so many patriots in this country who feel that the Olympics stand for something more than just sports. And the troops that support us are certainly heroes as well - a fact that barely needs repeating at this point.
It's great to remind ourselves that there isn't just one type of heroes in this world.
Wednesday, 12 February 2014
Is BusinessInsider or its readers the problem?
While perusing Twitter today, I came across a link to a Business Insider article. It was a standard BI type of article where the news was kept fairly high-level, digestible and concisely written - just a quick snapshot of the news and why it was important.
I think that there is a certain amount of that that is healthy for readers in today's fast-paced world. Many would argue that we can only take in so many pieces of information in a given day, so it is better to get as many 1000 feet views of numerous topics than it is to develop an in-depth understanding of a few select issues.
But too much of that and we start to lose the significance of issues by glancing over some of the nuances. And that is where I start to get a little frustrated with a publication like Business Insider. In addition to its click-baiting (save that for another day), it would prefer a gatling gun style approach where it guns down issues left and right rather than focusing on some truly solid reporting on bigger issues. Ultimately it is the reader who loses out when this happens.
Take for instance an article that came out just before the Olympics - 16 Crazy Anecdotes About Sex In The Olympic Village. Never mind the fact that the title of the article would seem to suggest that these are direct anecdotes the journalist acquired, the entire article is simply a "listicle" of a truly excellent piece of journalism that Sam Alipour put together for ESPN two years ago just before the 2012 London Olympics - Will you still medal in the morning?
The ESPN article is long by our "this article seems interest...holy shit there's a squirrel!!" attention spans. But I have read this ESPN article before and I can tell you that it is well worth the additional 15 minutes that it takes to go start to finish on it. It provides everyone with an authentic description of what it is like in the Olympic Village for an athlete - something which none of us will ever have a chance to experience.
The Business Insider version is a list of one line snippets that were pulled from the article and paired with random images. It took me about 30 seconds to go through the entire thing, told me literally nothing about the actual Olympic village itself and shed no insight on the great lengths that Alipur went through to acquire his information in the article.
So is Business Insider the problem? Or are the readers to blame? It is a little bit of both. On one hand, readers can demand some modicum of effective journalism rather than the laziness of turning an outstanding piece into a tiresome list. On the other hand, Business Insider should be pushing its journalists to produce content that is better than that.
Don't get me wrong, I am not condemning every story that appears on the website. I have seen some longform journalism on Business Insider that I truly enjoyed. I have also seen some great reporting on issues around business and technology. But articles like the one above cheapen the rest of those articles to the point that I frequently avoid reading Business Insider articles that people post on Twitter and Facebook.
Alipour leveraged an insane rolodex on contacts to provide this look into the Olympic Village. Business Insider took his work, gave him a one sentence credit at the top, turned it into a list, slapped a click-baiting title to it and called it complete. And that's where the issue comes in for me.
The next time you're reading an article like this on Business Insider or another similar website and they link back to the original piece - do yourself a favor and read the original. You'll be surprised by just how much you can learn and you just might put the pressure on Business Insider to do more reporting just like it.
For an example of Business Insider doing excellent reporting to show that they truly are capable of it, check out this article on the story behind AOL CEO Tim Cook firing an employee in front of the entire company - The Story Behind Why AOL CEO Tim Armstrong Fired An Employee In Front Of 1,000 Coworkers
I think that there is a certain amount of that that is healthy for readers in today's fast-paced world. Many would argue that we can only take in so many pieces of information in a given day, so it is better to get as many 1000 feet views of numerous topics than it is to develop an in-depth understanding of a few select issues.
But too much of that and we start to lose the significance of issues by glancing over some of the nuances. And that is where I start to get a little frustrated with a publication like Business Insider. In addition to its click-baiting (save that for another day), it would prefer a gatling gun style approach where it guns down issues left and right rather than focusing on some truly solid reporting on bigger issues. Ultimately it is the reader who loses out when this happens.
Take for instance an article that came out just before the Olympics - 16 Crazy Anecdotes About Sex In The Olympic Village. Never mind the fact that the title of the article would seem to suggest that these are direct anecdotes the journalist acquired, the entire article is simply a "listicle" of a truly excellent piece of journalism that Sam Alipour put together for ESPN two years ago just before the 2012 London Olympics - Will you still medal in the morning?
The ESPN article is long by our "this article seems interest...holy shit there's a squirrel!!" attention spans. But I have read this ESPN article before and I can tell you that it is well worth the additional 15 minutes that it takes to go start to finish on it. It provides everyone with an authentic description of what it is like in the Olympic Village for an athlete - something which none of us will ever have a chance to experience.
The Business Insider version is a list of one line snippets that were pulled from the article and paired with random images. It took me about 30 seconds to go through the entire thing, told me literally nothing about the actual Olympic village itself and shed no insight on the great lengths that Alipur went through to acquire his information in the article.
So is Business Insider the problem? Or are the readers to blame? It is a little bit of both. On one hand, readers can demand some modicum of effective journalism rather than the laziness of turning an outstanding piece into a tiresome list. On the other hand, Business Insider should be pushing its journalists to produce content that is better than that.
Don't get me wrong, I am not condemning every story that appears on the website. I have seen some longform journalism on Business Insider that I truly enjoyed. I have also seen some great reporting on issues around business and technology. But articles like the one above cheapen the rest of those articles to the point that I frequently avoid reading Business Insider articles that people post on Twitter and Facebook.
Alipour leveraged an insane rolodex on contacts to provide this look into the Olympic Village. Business Insider took his work, gave him a one sentence credit at the top, turned it into a list, slapped a click-baiting title to it and called it complete. And that's where the issue comes in for me.
The next time you're reading an article like this on Business Insider or another similar website and they link back to the original piece - do yourself a favor and read the original. You'll be surprised by just how much you can learn and you just might put the pressure on Business Insider to do more reporting just like it.
For an example of Business Insider doing excellent reporting to show that they truly are capable of it, check out this article on the story behind AOL CEO Tim Cook firing an employee in front of the entire company - The Story Behind Why AOL CEO Tim Armstrong Fired An Employee In Front Of 1,000 Coworkers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)